When people think about geoengineering the climate to stall or reverse climate change, they often think of university and government research labs. Given the scope and importance of such a project, it only seems natural that governments would be the ones to implement such a momentous and fraught project.
But there is now a new player on the scene: private companies promoting their technologies and capabilities to block sunlight in order to reduce the temperature of the Earth. I've opined previously about the dangers of altering the amount of sunlight reaching the Earth's surface here and here. Let me summarize the main risks:
1. Reducing the amount of sunlight that gets to the surface of the Earth, no matter how it is done (for example, through releasing reflective aerosols into the atmosphere or using a large mirror in space), may lead to unanticipated changes in precipitation, frequency and severity of storms, seasonal winds and other factors unevenly across the globe. Even if the global temperature falls, some areas may be subjected to ever more damaging floods or droughts that are made worse by these uncontrolled experiments in climate engineering.
2. Reducing sunlight will have no effect on the drivers of ocean acidification. Ocean acidification is caused by rising carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere which come primarily from the burning of fossil fuels and the felling of forests (which store carbon). The carbon dioxide released dissolves in waters everywhere making them more acidic. Ocean acidification is no small matter. As I detailed in this piece, "First, the entire food chain of the ocean could be short-circuited. Second, ocean acidification in combination with other human impacts on the ocean could result in mass extinctions. Third, no one knows how such changes might affect life on land which is by no means isolated from the ocean." Pretending that we are solving the problems associated with climate change without addressing carbon emissions is intellectually dishonest and very dangerous.
So, if we put capitalists in charge of engineering climate, they will do what capitalists are incentivized to do, namely, promote their particular approach regardless of the scientific backing for it or the risks associated with it. They will give generously to the campaign funds of politicians who must make the decision to fund it or not. And, there is also the option of simply bribing politicians directly with free trips, expensive gifts, and even cash. The outcome of such a process is unlikely to do anything other than enrich the capitalists who implement the climate engineering solution—using public money, of course.
It's worth noting that the engineering mind always tends toward "doing something" as a solution and "doing something" usually means engineering, production, assembly and deployment which costs money and produces profits. But human civilization is in dire need of the will to stop doing the things which are causing climate change. While there are whole industries devoted to reducing the amount of carbon released into the atmosphere—the solar and wind energy industries come to mind—the managers of such industries often push the idea that simply making a transition to green energy will allow us essentially to continue business as usual.
It is the business-as-usual message that needs to be challenged from the start. And it is the message that will almost certainly be proffered to the world's politicians when the climate geoengineering capitalists come to call.
Kurt Cobb is a freelance writer and communications consultant who writes frequently about energy and environment. His work has appeared in The Christian Science Monitor, Resilience, Common Dreams, Naked Capitalism, Le Monde Diplomatique, Oilprice.com, OilVoice, TalkMarkets, Investing.com, Business Insider and many other places. He is the author of an oil-themed novel entitled Prelude and has a widely followed blog called Resource Insights. He can be contacted at kurtcobb2001@yahoo.com.
No comments:
Post a Comment