Wednesday, February 09, 2005

The terminator is back, maybe

When Monsanto announced that it was ready to release so-called "terminator" seeds, that is, seeds that grow crops which are sterile and therefore cannot reproduce, the public outcry was so great that it put its plans on hold. There has been a de facto moratorium on creating and using such seeds ever since. But a Canadian group has learned that the Canadian government plans to seek a lifting of this moratorium at an upcoming United Nations meeting.

The problem with such seeds is that they make farmers completely dependent on multinational corporations since the crops don't produce any usable seed. My reading also leads me to conclude that the terminator gene could migrate into wild cousins of commonly grown crops and into non-GMO varieties with unpredictable and possibly catastrophic results. If anyone knows more about the genetic migration problem and where I could find additional information, please leave a comment or contact me by email.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Bumpy ride

That's what this financial writer predicts for 2005 and beyond. His main evidence for this is near the bottom of the piece where he details the decreasing number of large oil finds and the consistent gap between consumption and discovery since the 1980s. If you want to understand why, in the face of all our technology, discoveries are declining, read my previous post, Faith-based economics II: The case of oil's sudden scarcity.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Tuesday, February 08, 2005

Clueless

President Bush recently told The Wall Street Journal that nuclear power is a "renewable source of energy." (For the full interview go to the bottom of the linked article.) One might think that he got such an impression from reading the Journal's editorial page, a strong booster of nuclear energy and a world-renown source of misinformation, pure fantasy, and outright lies. But, since the president has already told us that he doesn't read newspapers, I think I'll chalk his mistake up to the fact that he's just plain clueless.

To assist the ongoing project of orienting the president to reality a group of 48 organizations sent him a short letter explaining his error. Perhaps someone on his staff will read it to him.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Report from New Zealand: How to wreck paradise

Family members of mine have lived in or made long visits to New Zealand, and they have always been completely taken with its charm: the friendly people, the slower pace of life, the egalitarian society, the clean environment, and the breathtaking natural beauty. But that was quite a while ago. New Zealand's embrace of the global economy is quickly destroying what had been the country's greatest assets. New Zealanders have now firmly joined the rest of the world on an unsustainable path as they buy more SUVs, build more suburbs and country palaces, and adopt the shop-til-you-drop attitude so prevalent in other consumer societies.

The author of the linked article reports that New Zealand officials dismiss talk of an impending peak in world oil production. They insist that huge oil finds are ahead that will push the peak back to 2067. Even if they are right (and this seems highly doubtful), what sense does it make to continue down a path that will lead to your own petroleum-inspired doom?

Perhaps the most telling thing in this piece is its discussion of local government, a discussion that points to a possible way to begin moving politically toward a more sustainable society. National governments in New Zealand and elsewhere seem incapable of even considering the possibility that their current joint trajectory might really be a suicide pact.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Monday, February 07, 2005

The answer is blowin' in the wind

Lester Brown offers a doable strategy for cutting gasoline consumption by 70 percent: wind power combined with hybrid vehicles that have a second battery which allow local trips to be entirely electric. As I've been saying, wind power seems to be the most likely candidate to become a major source of renewable electricity. The problem in transportation has been that you can't power a car or truck with a windmill, or can you? That's really what Brown is suggesting; it's simply being done through the power grid rather than directly.

He admits that not everyone will welcome wind turbines in their communities, but he adds that rural populations, especially farmers and ranchers are finding them an excellent way to enhance their livelihoods.

Could Brown's vision work? I say, yes. Will we embrace it? The jury is out, but the robust sales of hybrid cars are a good leading indicator.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

It's nice to share

The G-7 nations are suddenly eager to see information on actual oil reserves in such countries as Saudi Arabia and Venezuela where state-owned oil companies dominate. A Saudi spokesman responded, "Data on reserves is information and information is power.'' Why give away that power? The spokesman apparently couldn't think of a good reason.

More important, however, is that fact that the G-7 is requesting reserve data for the first time ever so far as I can tell. Don't they believe that the marketplace will take care of imbalances in oil supply and demand? After years of low oil prices, are they afraid that OPEC has the upper hand? Or could they be looking for information about when a possible peak in world oil production might occur?

There's also a call to reduce "barriers to investment," codespeak for opening up state-owned oil lands to foreign oil companies who will have incentives to pump the oil more quickly than their state-run counterparts. For more on why private companies tend to produce more oil faster, see my post Faith-based economics III: Why the market price doesn't tell us the true state of oil reserves.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Friday, February 04, 2005

It depends on what the meaning of "organic" is

Arthur Harvey, an organic blueberry farmer in Maine, thought the National Organic Program (NOP), the arm of the USDA that oversees the organic label, had gone too far in diluting and weakening the act governing the label. In October 2003 he sued the agency. His claims were rejected by a federal district court, but last week an appeals court accepted some of Harvey's arguments and has directed that changes be made in the NOP. Organic Business News, a monthly newsletter, (sorry, it's only available by mail) summarized Harvey's concerns in its December issue as follows:
1. NOP cannot grant a blanket exemption from the National List [of allowed synthetic substances] for "any non-organically produced agricultural product" when it is not commercially available.

2. The NOP cannot allow the certification of products with less than 95% organic ingredients.

3. The NOP cannot allow synthetic ingredients in organically-labeled processed foods when OFPA (the Organic Foods Production Act) forbids the addition of synthetic ingredients to processed foods.

4. Wholesalers and distributors who meet the definition of handlers and handling operations in OFPA cannot be excluded from the law.

5. Certifiers should be allowed to give free advice to their clients to help them overcome barriers to certification, even though they receive money from the clients. [The regulation against this was promulgated to prevent a conflict of interest among those who certify organic status for farming and processing operations. Private consultants who have no say over certification currently do the bulk of the advice-giving.]

6. Dairy animals cannot be fed 80% organic feed for the first nine months of the year prior to being sold as organic, because the law says that dairy animals must be fed organically produced feed for not less than 12 months prior to sale.

7. Certifiers should be allowed to use their own private certification seals when their standards exceed those of the USDA.
The appeals court agreed with Harvey on three issues:
1. The NOP had no authority to allow some 38 synthetic ingredients into the processing and handling of organic foods.

2. Dairy herds must be fed 100 percent organic feed during the required 12-month conversion process.

3. Proposals to use non-organic agricultural ingredients in food labelled organic will have to be reviewed in each case for each processor to determine whether an organic version is not commercially available. No blanket exemptions are allowed.
Few people took Harvey seriously until his suit was joined by the Organic Consumers Association, Sierra Club, Public Citizen, Inc., NOFA-Mass, Greenpeace USA, Waterkeeper Alliance and prominent individuals in the organic community. With their help he continued to pursue the case. The case might still be appealed, and the district court is being asked to clarify issues surrounding the blanket exemption issue.

Unfortunately, the case is just another example of how lawyers rather than farmers will now be fighting over what it means for something to be organic. This is what Dennis Blank, editor and publisher of Organic Business News, told me he feared would happen. When the lawyers get a hold of the law, it won't be about what's organic anymore. It'll be about who has the best lawyers. The organic community got lucky this time. Will they be so lucky in the future?

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Wednesday, February 02, 2005

Life imitates art: Three Days of the Condor

Perhaps some of you will remember the 1975 movie "Three Days of the Condor" with Robert Redford as a young CIA analyst who discovers an unauthorized plan by a rogue group inside the CIA to take over Middle East oilfields. That such a plan would be unauthorized and even scandalous must certainly seem quaint to us now. I was thinking about the final scene of the movie recently and found this script of it online. Redford plays "Turner," the CIA analyst. Cliff Robertson plays "Higgins," the CIA's New York chief, who is trying to hunt down Turner when Turner surprises him on the street. The scene now seems eerily prescient:
TURNER
Do we have plans to invade the Middle East?

HIGGINS
Are you crazy?

TURNER
Am I?

HIGGINS
Look, Turner...

TURNER
Do we have plans?

HIGGINS
No. Absolutely not.
(then)
We have games. That's all. We play games. "What if?", "How many men?", "What would it take?", "Is there a cheaper way of destabilizing the regime?"
(quieter)
That's what we're paid to do.

TURNER
So...Atwood just took the games too seriously. He was really going to do it...wasn't he?

HIGGINS
It was a renegade operation! Atwood knew 54/12 could never authorize it: not with all the heat on the company.
TURNER
Suppose there'd been no heat? And I hadn't stumbled on the plan? Nobody had?

HIGGINS
(shrugs)
Different ballgame. The fact is, it wasn't a bad plan. It could've worked.

TURNER
Jesus--What is it with you people? You think not getting caught in a lie is the same as telling the truth.

HIGGINS
It's simple economics, Turner...There's no argument. Oil now, 10 or 15 years, it'll be food, or plutonium. Maybe sooner than that. What do you think the people will want us to do then?

TURNER
Ask them!

HIGGINS
Now?
(shakes head)
Huh-uh. Ask them when they're running out. When it's cold at home and the engines stop and people who aren't used to hunger...go hungry! They won't want us to ask...
(quiet savagery:)
They'll just want us to get it for them.


How sadly, darkly true.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

The hydrogen economy: It's really a nuclear economy

For those who maintain visions of a hydrogen economy delivering us from the evils of petroleum, there is one currently available solution: nuclear power. As you've been reminded over and over again on this blog, hydrogen is not an energy source; it is an energy carrier. That means it has to be extracted from somewhere else (probably water) using a genuine energy source, a process that requires considerably more energy input than the hydrogen will yield. This piece outlines what it would take to do it with nuclear power and why other avenues are simply not feasible. The writer admits that he is not even going to attempt to deal with the nuclear waste problem. But, that comes as no surprise. Nobody wants to deal with it.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)

Tuesday, February 01, 2005

We'll figure that out later

The nuclear power industry is abandoning its long-held position that a permanent nuclear waste disposal site must be approved before a new nuclear plant can be built. Now that energy prices are high and the administration in the White House is friendly to nuclear power, the industry is ready to move ahead. But, as usual, the great believers in the free market want handouts in the form of subsidies and insurance guarantees. (No insurance company in its right mind will insure a nuclear power plant without a government guarantee or legal limitation and right now that limit for payouts is $560 million.) This quote from The New York Times piece cited above shows that the industry is quite matter-of-fact about its desire to spread its costs to the public at large:
A spokesman for the Nuclear Energy Institute, the industry's lobbying group, Steven Kerekes, said, "We believe it's the government's job to find a solution, whether that be Yucca Mountain or somewhere else."
I wonder if the nuclear industry will also be eager to spreads its profits around to the public as well. I kind of doubt it.

(Comments are open to all. After clicking on "Comments," click on "Or Post Anonymously" if you don't have an account. See the list of environmental blogs on my sidebar.)